Products & Services

Criteria Cluster
Ratings Summary by “Criteria Cluster”

For ease of summarization, the 15 criteria in have been aggregated into the following seven Criteria Clusters, which are the focus of the company-by-company evaluations in the Regional Sector Reports.

Environmental Management Cluster includes Criterion 1, on the adoption and implementation of environmental management systems such as ISO 14001. Strong positive scores are given to a combination of management systems. Criterion 2 reflects the scope of engagement by upper management and the company’s Board of Directors. The Cluster Score is an average of these two criteria.

Supply Chain and Life Cycle Impacts Cluster includes Criterion 3, on performance requirements for raw material suppliers, and Criterion 4 on the use of life cycle assessments. The Cluster Score here is an average of both criteria.

Balance of 3rd Party Awards, Costs of Sanctions, and Transparency Cluster includes Criterion 5, recognitions and awards, seen as an indicator of corporate environmental performance, Criterion 6, evaluating the significance and scope of spills, sanctions and clean-up costs being born by the company, and Criterion 7, the overall transparency of the company’s environmental reports and audits. Transparency covers all aspects from raw materials brought in, through to manufacturing and residuals, and stewardship of products.

The Conservation of Water and Watersheds Cluster incorporates two criteria, Criterion 8 on pursuit of efficient water use and protection of water quality, and Criterion 9 on watershed protection, including the minimizing of land conversions.

Nutrient Enrichment, Acid Gases and Toxics Cluster is represented only by Criterion 10, with seven metrics measuring the management of risks from emissions, discharges to aqueous environments, toxic chemical or metal releases, and solid waste considerations. Management of externalities from all of these are important aspects of a forward-looking environmental conservation strategy.

Energy and Greenhouse Gas Management Cluster includes Criterion 11, energy conservation support through planning and management, and Criterion 12, steps toward managing constituents such as greenhouse gases along with other aspects of urban climate management (through “green” buildings and conservation landscaping of industrial sites). Although relatively few companies have such programs in place, those who do should be recognized for a cost effective form of corporate competition.

Green Layer Productivity and Biological Diversity Conservation Cluster includes Criterion 13, sustaining green layer productivity and carbon storage, and Criterion 14, the conservation of biological diversity. Both have relevance for forest or industrial agriculture companies, but both also are important for electricity generation, chemicals, and suburban land development. Attention here must be directed as well to the company’s management of its supply chain.

Human Health Impacts Cluster considers only Criterion 15, with up to five metrics. Health issues are not weighted heavily in sectors such as forest and paper, but are weighted heavily in chemicals and other sectors.

 
©2004 ICValue Inc.